- Published on
Lo, come the horsemen / To bring round the end"- Wayfarer, "The Dusklands"
There's something undeniable about the aesthetic of the western. I am an arty urban liberal who has been on a horse once as a kid at a summer camp, but I've always harbored a low-key love of the American Old West. I think Unforgiven is an essentially perfect movie. My ideal Father's Day activity would be making my family watch 3:10 to Yuma with me. In college, I was pretty obsessed with the author Joe R. Lansdale, particularly his "weird western" stories. I think the Old West holds allure for Americans because, as a relatively young country, it presents the opportunity for our own myths and legends. I know that is part of the attraction for Wayfarer, the Denver-based metal band. Their early albums combined the sounds and subjects of the American West with black metal, rather than draw on the historical and cultural elements of the genre's Scandinavian originators. Over time, the Western elements of their sound grew stronger, and on Riders of the Setting Sun, the band have completely divorced from their black metal roots.
Riders of the Setting Sun is a fascinating example of a band evolving their sound. Certainly, the band has been steadily expanding their repertoire of sounds over their last few albums. Their last album, American Gothic, featured more clean vocals than anything the band had done to date, yet was still essentially a black metal album at heart. Riders of the Setting Sun, however, is most certainly not a black metal album, One could argue that it's not a metal album at all. While not at all similar in sound, Riders of the Setting Sun is a good analog to Deafheaven's Infinite Granite and its preceding album, Ordinary Corrupt Human Love. On Ordinary Corrupt Human Love, Deafheaven incorporated alternative rock and shoegaze elements that would go on to become the primary soundscape of Infinite Granite. The transition from American Gothic to Riders of the Setting Sun is similar, except with Americana and post-punk sounds.
Riders of the Setting Sun is as stark of a direction change as Infinite Granite. As previously mentioned, the black metal roots of the band have been entirely stripped away on this album. In its place are clean vocals, galloping country rhythms, and slide guitar. Yet Riders of the Setting Sun isn't strictly a country album, either. The album opens with an ominous spoken word guest spot by Steve Von Till and closes with the dreamy, shoegaze-inflected track "Prairies of Babylon" that features fellow Denver musician Midwife. In between are guest performances by David Eugene Edwards of Sixteen Horsepower and Wovenhand, Kelly Schilling of Dreadnought, and Jay Munly of Slim Cessna's Auto Club. There's also a cover of "Casey's Last Ride" by Kris Kristofferson and other surprises.
From the opening of "The Dusklands" to the end of "Prairies of Babylon," Riders of the Setting Sun effectively transports the listener into a world of dusty, windswept plains and dimly lit saloons. As a comprehensive mood piece, it's an incredible album that rewards the listener for sitting through it from start to finish with an attentive ear. At the same time, each track is entirely successful on its own. The tracks with high-profile guests like the brimstone preacher-voiced Edwards rightly have received a lot of advanced attention, but the tracks that only feature the core band are just as exciting. Mid-album track "Fell Spur" shines with its lap steel guitar and singalong chanting chorus. "Hollow Hears on the Trail to Eden" starts gently and slowly picks up steam, culminating in one of the album's most metal moments, with fuzzy electric guitar dominating the final third. While not as lengthy or epic as a traditional post metal track, the steady build certainly pulls from the genre. Can we call it a "post Americana" track? Maybe.
Wayfarer at Fire in the Mountains, 2026
Deciding what genre Wayfarer now occupies is a fun exercise. They've certainly broken completely free of their original black metal roots, and other tags don't feel quite right. It's too gentle and subtle of an album to be called a true metal album, yet there is still enough metal DNA across its eight songs to say it's not that, either. There are country, folk, and Americana sounds across this album from start to finish, but enough shoegaze fuzz and cinematic aura to make those tags feel reductive as well. I've talked myself into it: Wayfarer is a post Americana band moving forward.
Whatever you choose to call it, Riders of the Setting Sun is simply excellent. Wayfarer have made a quantum leap in their sound, and the transition completely works. Riders of the Setting Sun is catchy, inventive, and dare I say it, flawless. It's been an incredibly strong year for music, and Riders of the Setting Sun still stands out. It's one of the best records of the year.
I know there will be some longstanding Wayfarer fans who are disappointed by the totality of their transformation, at least initially. To those fans, I say give Riders of the Setting Sun a chance and you will discover what I have: a band that forged its own trail. Years ago, Wayfarer found a path that was pioneered by others. Now, they're creating their own path, finding their own way across the the prairies, into the light of the setting sun.
Wayfarer's Riders of the Setting Sun is out November 20 via Vesperian.