METAL. FITNESS. MISCELLANEOUS NONSENSE

POWER METAL FREE SINCE 2025

BOTH KINDS OF HEAVY

Published on
Image description

As the year draws to a close, the number of high-profile albums is starting to dwindle and the first best of the year coverage is popping up. These two forces converged this week for me with the new Down album, a release I wasn't sure I was going go cover because of, well, the Phil Anselmo issue. If you're familiar with the man, you know what I'm talking about. Let's get into it. 

Cards on the table: I saw Pantera several times back in the day, and have seen Down twice since the infamous Dimebash incident. Both times they were part of a larger bill and never the primary draw for me. Before deciding to watch their set, I did a lot of reading and determined that Anselmo did seem to genuinely repent his actions (although I can't seem to find the articles that made me change my mind now), but even so, I remain less than fully comfortable promoting their music. This isn't virtue signaling on my part - I'm simply trying to be fully honest about my mindset going into this album. I likely would have skipped covering Volume V. However, the fact that the Anselmo seems to have been broadly accepted back into a metal mainstream that has become markedly more liberal and less tolerant of intolerance, combined with the strong reviews, convinced me that I should give it a listen. 


Unfortunately, Phil Anselmo remains a barrier for me to truly enjoy this album. But not in the way that I expected. 

First, the good. The talent of Down's members is undeniable. The heavy, smoky blues-influenced rock that is Down's calling card is still an effective and appealing sound. The blues-tinged twin guitar assault of Kirk Windstein and Pepper Keenan hasn't lost any of its power. Jimmy Bower on drums and Pat Bruders on bass are a tight and driving rhythm section. The production is crisp, clean, and effective, and there are undoubtedly several tracks that will give listeners the mighty stank face. Having King Diamond guest on a track called "Merciful Fate" is one of those "it's a fine line between brilliant and stupid" moments, but it's always a pleasure to hear the King, even if he feels a little underutilized on this particular track. 


For me, Anselmo's vocals are the real weak point of this album. When I saw him a few months back opening for Slayer, I thought his performance was strangely listless (he was much better a few years prior at Psycho Las Vegas, in fairness) to the point that I was wondering if he was having an off night. Across the entirety of Volume V, I found his vocals lacking. Don't get me wrong, they're not embarrassing (for the most part), but it's very, very clear that he's lost a lot of his range and vocal ability over the years. 


Losing vocal range over the years is completely normal, and while Anselmo never had a huge octave range compared to some other singers, he used to have a much wider bag of tricks than what we hear on Volume V. He used to switch between truly clean vocals, what I'll call his "gruff vocals," which are still clean and intelligible, but with a good bit of gravel added in, and some good old-fashioned screaming. On Volume V, he is mostly constrained to his mid-range gruff vocals. It's not very fair to compare a song off the first Down album from 1995 to anything off the new 2026 album, but if you listen to a track like "Rehab" before Volume V, it's pretty obvious how much Anselmo's vocal abilities have diminished. 


While Anselmo's vocal arsenal is diminished, he's still quite good at at his mid-range gravelly voice. Unfortunately, when he tries to push outside out of the gruff vocals window, it mostly doesn't work. The most egregious example is on "Ozz," a ballad about the loss of the great Ozzy Osbourne. At the end of it, Anselmo tries a for a big, belting soul singer moment. It sounds more like a Saturday Night Live impression of a big, belting soul singer. What should be Volume V's most earnest moment is its most cringe-inducing. 


With Anselmo's vocals so much more limited than they used to be, it's far easier to notice that the lyrics on Volume V are also lacking. Again, I don't think there's anything outright embarrassing about them, but there's nothing particularly unique or gripping about them, either. Consider the opening lyrics of "Twice-Told Tale," the album's final track: "Whispered in a chilling voice / (We) Heard it from fifty yards away / He was insane / Like the rest of you / This is a twice-told tale." 


These could be lyrics from any metal album, but they could also be the opening lines of a Goosebumps book. I don't think anyone has ever claimed that Anselmo's greatest strength is his skill at a lyricist, but it would be nice to see a little introspection or maturity rather than generic horror stories. 


I've been pretty negative on Volume V, but I do understand why it is getting generally positive reviews. As I said above, the band can still write a killer riff. All the tracks on the first half of the album are pretty solid bangers (the second half is more forgettable). If you are looking for simply more Down tracks, then you will likely not be disappointed. This album delivers the smoky, swampy, blues metal you'd expect. But at a certain point, long-running bands have to adapt to their changing abilities and adjust their approach to how they write to those abilities. On Volume V, Down hasn't done that, and the record suffers as a result. 


Down's Volume V is out Friday, November 20 via Nuclear Blast Records.he

0 Comments